Notes on the Self-colonising Cultures
by Alexander Kiossev
In 1842 Konstantin Fotinov, the creator of the
first Bulgarian magazine Lyuboslovie, published
a remarkable appeal which treats ardently and with pain all that
lack of civilization by the Bulgarians: "Where are
their daily newspapers and magazines, or the weekly and monthly
ones? Where are their artistic magazines, their rhetoric, mathematics,
logic, physics, philosophy, etc., etc., which man needs more than
bread? Where is their history, written in detail and widely spread
among people, such as the other nations have and which would help
us to stand side by side with the others and make the others aware
of the fact that we are as verbal as the rest of God's creatures?"
The Bulgarian press during the National Revival abounded
in similar appeals, treating the lack of civilization. They all
represent patriotic complaints about various shortages - about
lack of cultural institutions, literary or scientific achievements,
good manners or great Bulgarian poets. But yet, in spite of their
variety and heterogeneity one can see that all these complaints
expressed much more a morbid awareness of the absence of a
whole civilizational model rather than of some concrete civilizational
achievement. Fotinov's patriotic appeal would be quite absurd
if he only complained of the lack of Bulgarian physics, for example.
It is clear that his enumeration is synecdocal - it includes just
a part of all the systematic deficiencies. The real question behind
this enumeration is: Where is ... everything in Bulgaria?
Where is the total, complete Bulgarian culture, built up according
to the European model?
Thus, in the genealogical knot of the Bulgarian national
culture there exists the morbid consciousness of an absence -
a total, structural, non-empirical absence. The Others - i.e.
the neighbors, Europe, the civilized World, etc. possess all that
we lack; they are all that we are not. The identity of this
culture is initially marked, and even constituted by, the pain,
the shame - and to formulate it more generally - by the trauma
of this global absence. The origin of this culture arises
as a painful presence of absences and its history could be narrated,
in short, as centuries-old efforts to make up for and eliminate
the traumatic lacks.
I wonder whether it is not possible to call such cultures self-colonizing?
The reason for such a strange name is rather simple - in such
cultures the social and symbolic "Order of Modernity"
is not carried out by means of forceful colonization in which
the native culture is totally conquered and destroyed by European
conquistadors, and the natives are exterminated or enslaved (as
in the case of the American Indians or of some primitive cultures
in Africa). But this order is scarcely the result of traditionally
indicated economic and social reasons either. The economic explanation
for the rise of the modern nations has many deficiencies and to
criticize all of them in detail would make us go astray. Suffice
it to say here that there is no sufficient explanation for why
the process that determined the expansion of economic rationality
remains isolated within an irrationally1 articulated territory-culture
and doesn't expand (or expands with other rates and specificity)
beyond its boundaries2. Being neutral, rational and universal,
the economy of money and markets can not achieve boundaries of
its own and in itself it is not able to become precisely a
national economy. It needs to be doubled by a second one -
the economy of symbols and models of identity, regulating the
relationship of nations and groups to themselves, as well as,
their relationship to the Others3. And in the self-colonizing
cultures they, these symbols and models I have already mentioned,
are symbols of absence. Though it sounds unusual, in such cultures
even the national territory in question could present itself merely
as a daydream, a geographic vision, as
a longing caused by an absence, and not as a real institutional
force4.
To put it simpler - the economic explanation can not answer why
the new economic, media, industrial, etc. relations acquire precisely
this concrete national and territorial form - for this explanation
always presupposes what it tries to explain - the already existing
national identity embodied in an articulated territory with clear
boundaries.
The hypothesis of this text is, therefore, the following: the
birth of these nations is connected with a very specific symbolic
economy. It seems that the self-colonizing cultures import alien
values and civilizational models by themselves and that they lovingly
colonize their own authenticity trough these foreign models.
Yet which are, in fact, the cultures that we call, using a strange
meta-phor, "self-colonizing" cultures?
From the point of view of the modern globalization of the world,
there are cultures which are not central enough, not timely and
big enough in comparison to the "Great Nations". At
the same time they are insufficiently alien, insufficiently distant
and insufficiently backward, in contrast to the African tribes,
for example. That's why, in their own troubled embryo, somewhere
in the periphery of Civilization, they arise in the space of a
generative doubt: We are European, although perhaps not
to a real extent. This is a precondition for a quite peculiar
identity and a quite peculiar modernization. They arise through
the constitutive trauma that: We are not Others (seeing
in the Others the representatives of the Universal), and this
trauma is also connected with the awareness that they have appeared
too late and that their life is a reservoir of lacks of civilization.
A rough structural analogy between cultures of entirely different
types is possible here. We know from ethnology that the symbolic
economy of every human society arises, in a sense, in a similar
way - around the trauma of a certain great Absence. The Creator-God
(Icelandic Poluga, Australian Bungjil, African Olorun) created
the world and after that left it; the Biblical Jehovah created
man and after that expelled him from himself and Paradise5. The
Sacred One, which Rudolf Otto, the great theoretician and historian
of religions, calls Das ganz Andere, is always separated
in another absent modality of the Cosmos, entirely different from
the profane life which, in each part, exists merely in so far
as it feels the painful lack of it, and is homesick for its ultimate
reality.
The self-colonizing cultures carry out a great replacement - they
put an alien civilization model in the structural place where
the figure of Das ganz Andere, the
absent Transcendence, the Universal, used to be. They adopt its
symbols as universal generative schemata at the point of their
genesis. In its own self-consciousness, self-legitimation and
propaganda, this Alien (equal to the expanding, rational and entzaubert
modern world) is known to represent itself as an embodiment
of the main stream in history and of the Universal fate of mankind.
In contrast to this narcissistic ideology of the West, the self-colonizing
nations suffer a tragic paradox - for them the Alien is the
Universal but the opposite is also true - The Universal
remains forever alien. It is a fatal coincidence between The
Great Other and the Alien which dooms the self-colonizing nations
to the feeling that the universal values are never their values
but values of Das ganz Andere - the civilized world.
In contrast to pre-modern society the otherness of the aliens
and the foreigners stops being associated with the Demonic and
becomes normative.
That is to say - by adopting these alien universal models, the
self-colonizing cultures traumatize themselves - for they also
adopt their own inferiority, their own painful lack of essential
Substance and Universality. Thus, in the economy of their secular
values the archetypal structural place of the absent God turned
out to be replaced by the deified West. The image of the West
itself becomes split - it is, on one hand, the empirical West,
the "great Nations and Powers" (which could also be
hostile, as the ceaseless wars, diplomatic and economic conflicts
constantly proved), but at the same time it has lost its empirical
features and has coincided with the Essential and the Universal,
while receiving a hidden transcendent aura in spite of the secular
ideology of Modernity.
And yet, how could we explain the fact that these peculiar cultures
lack not only any resistance against colonization through Western
symbolic patterns, any resistance to the symbol-invasion of the
Alien (resistance so inevitable in every violent colonization
- even the fatalistic North American Indians resisted the Spanish
conquistadors to a certain extent), but they adopt the alien models
with love, ardor and desire? How could we also explain the fact
that they display a certain unaccountable naivetО: they not only
welcome the expanding universalistic ideology of the foreigners
which makes them marginal and undeveloped, but they fall in love
with it as well? How could we explain the fact that these cultures
"suffer" because the Alien-Universal is not present
in its "civilizational totality", with all its "physics",
"mathematics", "rhetoric", "logic",
"daily newspapers", "artistic magazines",
etc.? How is this unexplainable childish mistake possible - to
confuse the West with God?
The reason for this naivetО is in fact rather simple: these cultures
simply did not exist before this confusion - they arose
through it. The suffering from this absence and the desire to
acquire the alien cultural models are constitutive as regards
their "own" identity. This suffering and these burning
desires are the sti-mulating forces for the building of the real
dominant institutions of Modernity in these regions - the educational
and public ones. Schools, different types of educational institutions
and later the universities, produced and spread the Western symbols
and models - a much more wanted commodity in the European periphery
than English cloth, French wines or German machines.
For all these reasons such cultures could be, quite inaccurately
and metaphorically, called self-colonizing cultures. And perhaps
it is high time to abandon this metaphor which has already exhausted
its heuristic potential. We are already in a position to see that
the main presupposition of this metaphor is a logical contradiction:
that it is by and for themselves (through social agents born and
raised in their own bosom and not by foreign invaders or missionaries)
that such cultures "conquer" themselves and impose foreign
values on themselves. The metaphor "self-colonization"
presupposes that in some hypothetical historical times, when there
were no traumas and suffering, there already existed a social
agent with his own stable identity - a presupposition which contradicts
the empirically proven fact that before the symbolical "self-conquering"
such "Self", such an identical social agent, did not
exist at all. Furthermore, the metaphor presupposes that later
this social agent became in some way crazy - he discovered an
inferiority complex in himself, abandoned his own values and began
to "conquer" and "colonize" himself by lovingly
using alien values. In that manner he, this agent, corrupted his
own authenticity by dooming himself to impossible desires for
non-existing realities - poetry, mathematics, theater, logic,
etc. But the error and the trauma are actually constitutive -
they, in fact, have not conquered but engendered these cultures.
Without the alien European model of the educated and the emancipated
Nation, which such a national ideologist as Fotinov so selflessly
imported and propagated, without the model of the educational
system in general and the literal translation of Western institutions
- school, university, press, public domain, administration, jurisdiction,
infrastructure, etc., the local rural patriarchal communities
on the Balkans would never have reached "national self-consciousness".
The very "national self-consciousness" is, in its structural
totality, an adopted Western model. The idea that certain "We"
fell suddenly in love and began to apply the values, the symbolic
and institutional order of certain "Them" (thus self-colonizing
itself) is, of course, wrong. In fact, on the level of close examination
of the empirical historical data, the genealogy of modern nations
on the Periphery begins not with its own "We" but from
a derogatory, mocking "You" - from the trauma of concrete
intellectuals who, in their practical relations to the "more
civilized", have been humiliated many times over (they have
been shouted at, "Hey, you, Bulgarian!" more often and
with more rage then the rest). It can be easily proven that this
has happened to every one of the Bulgarian intellectuals
from the period of the so called "Revival", who experienced
similar humiliations in their cultural contacts with some more
developed foreign nation - this applies for Paisiy, and for Peter
Beron, and for Fotinov, all the way to that great symbolic machine
for production of national identity, the poet called Ivan Vazov.
In this de profundis of humiliation that they are
born inferior and second rate, such intellectuals experienced
in a kind of a negative ecstatic vision all their lacks and shortages
as shame and pain: "Where is our rhetoric, mathematics,
logic, physics, philosophy, etc., etc. that man needs more then
bread? Where is our own_"us"?
Such traumatic cultures inevitably engender some misleading
sublimative rationalizations in order to suppress the memory of
their own birth-trauma. These rationalizations are not accidental
but substantial - because they belong to the structural-and-generative
necessity of this cultural type.
The first of them consists in the fact that in such cultures the
Birth of the Nation manifests itself always as a Re-Birth, as
a Revival of the Nation. The new modern type of culture and collective
constructs by necessity a historical Narrative of its own - it
invents for itself a far going historical Past that allows it
to identify itself with phenomena which are absolutely different
in structure - medieval Empires and ancient philosophers, rural
magic and rituals, kings, dynasties and saints, patriarchal sexual
ethics, sometimes even mythological ancestors or transcendental
origins of the nation. All this is meant to self-convince such
a culture that its own historical time has not started at the
traumatic point but has been continuous from some honorable Past
towards the glorious Future of the Nation. In this perspective,
the humiliating birth-trauma of such cultures seems to be merely
a transitory unpleasant incident, which will be overcome and entirely
forgotten during the stream of History - the provisional and accidental
Absence of civilization will be replaced through its happy Presence.
The second rationalization consists in the fact that such societies
engender necessarily two symmetrical, competing, conflicting and
equally mistaken doctrines. The first-one is called Westernization
or Europeanization - it presents the historical
temporality in an oversimplified manner - as an "athletic"
competition, as a running distance where the "civilizational"
drop-back could be compensated for by "enlightened"
sprinting. This doctrine has the pseudo-universalism of one "pregressivistic"
doctrine that measures the value of life by the quantity of the
"civilizational achievements". The second one is called
Nativism - it looks for and often finds (i.e. invents)
the lost "authentic substance" of the Nation, before
it has been corrupted by aliens, and then idealizes it in a bucolic
manner. This doctrine, of course, struggles against any new corrupting
influences and gives birth to the most vehement nationalistic
ideologies and dangerous sacralizations of the "native".
The third sublimative rationalization of the birth trauma, probably
the most important and determinative of the other ones, is enfolding
on a deeper semantic level. It is an attempt to reverse the hierarchies
of the Symbolic Order adopted from Europe (= the West, the civilized
world, the true humanity) - it attempts to reverse the relationship
between the unmarked and the marked members of the binary oppositions,
which constitute this Order and which articulate the non-symmetrical
relationship between the "Ours" and "The Alien".
It is well known that in each non-traumatic collective the "Ours",
in its ideal essence, manifests itself for the members of the
collective ecstatically and always in terms of Presence, Good,
Beauty, Truth, Purity, Harmony - whereas the Alien is connected
with Absence, Chaos, Impurity, Lie, Ugliness, Formlessness. At
the point of their origin (where they interiorize and transform
as their own norm the gaze of the other), the traumatic collectives
experience this binarism from its dark side - they experience
their Self-ness as impure, non-true, absent, etc. - it is a simple
lack of essence, a virtuallity which still lacks a civilizational
form and could be experienced only in the mode of shame. In the
further development of such cultures, however, as its sublimative
and rationalizing national ideology expands itself in its full
scope, there occurs the already mentioned attempt to reverse
the oppositions - the marked members are represented as unmarked.
Thus, the impure becomes pure, the lack of essence is transformed
into a faith in an essential organic kernel of the "nativeness".
But the same mechanism of sublimation works with non-national
collectives as well. Thus, "the last will be the first"
turns out to be the Biblical cure-all for all "repressed
and humiliated"; thus, suffering raises the spirit of the
humiliated and the offended; thus, the famous slogan of the Afro-American
movement "black is beautiful" could loose its presumed
originality by being contextualized in some general typology of
the traumatic collectives and their ideologies.
The birth of Bulgarian culture abounds with such examples as well.
Here the shame must become pride, the "don't have" -
"have", the absence - presence, etc. This paradoxical
operation of the subliminal reversal functions already in the
legendary entry exclamation of Paisiy, the monk from Mount Athos,
which opens his "Slavic-Bulgarian History", the almost
mythical text written in 1762 and considered to be the very first
text of the Bulgarian Revival: "Oh thou unreasonable,
oh you silly fool! Why are you ashamed to call yourself a Bulgarian?
Is it not true that Bulgarians have had a kingdom and a state
of their own? Among all the Slavic peoples it was precisely the
Bulgarians who were the most glorious nation - they were the first
to crown their kings, they were the first to have an Orthodox
patriarch, they were the first to be baptized and they have conquered
the greatest territories."
For a long time we have been used to thinking that the
rhetorical strategy of this phrase, as well as, of the entire
"History_" is quite clear - it attempts to carry out
the already mentioned reversal of the binary oppositions and to
transform the negative into positive, the ignorance into glorious
history, the lack of achievements into presence of honorable figures
and great events in the historical memory - the shame and the
formlessness into pride and identity. What is rarely mentioned
is the fact that under the layer of its conscious rhetoric this
text expresses something quite different as well - it reproduces
the trauma it is trying to overcome and sublimate. I don't only
mean that the relation with the others - "wise Greeks, mighty
Romans, Slavic people", is constitutive and quite obvious
in a certain sense. I mean that the appeal to pride all which
is Bulgarian is doubled-up with a curse. The dream to be part
of a glorious collective is doubled-up with an ethical and emotional
gesture of distancing oneself, even repulsion from the very same
collective which is simultaneously "brothers - ignorant Bulgarians"
and a crowd of "unreasonable and silly fools". By calling
his compatriots silly fools Paisiy not only transgresses
but also repeats the humiliation and the offense that he himself
had been subjected to on Mount Athos. The internal alie-nation
from the "native" is not only in the unavoidable awareness
for the "wise" and the "mighty" who have turned
out to be Other by necessity - it is much deeper. Traumatic cultures
can not accept any absence with calm - it awakens pathetic arguments
or straight forward unfounded paradoxical reversals which aim
to show that the absence is somehow a presence. But the reverse
is also valid - each presence is under the threat of actually
turning-out to be an absence, each sublimation is unstable and
risks being a hidden re-enactment of the trauma, together with
everything else.
Aren't we then forced to describe the historical rhythm of such
traumatic, self-colonizing cultures as a constant repetition and
return? Maybe the constitutive traumas can not be overcome and
they will occur over and over again in the form of various historical
symptoms - as a Wiederkehr des VerdrКngten - a recurrence
of the suppressed?
Or maybe this is just a reminder that the history of Modernity
could not be written as a composite history consisting of the
histories of many separate nations (that means as histories of
the Native and the Alien), but should be written (described, analyzed,
criticized, etc.) globally, as a history of the entire process
of asymmetrical modernization, transgressing the boundaries of
the established historiographical narratives about states, cultures
and ideologies?6
Notes:
1.My point here is that these processes seem to be irrational
from the point of view of the economic rationality. By the articulation
of national state territory and the determination of its border-lines
there are two such form-creating "irrationalities" at
work. The first realizes itself in the identity of the so called
"political nation", based on the common political will
of certain citizens to live together, to form an unified national
society. The second is expressed in the identification of the
so called "cultural nation" (Kulturnation), based on
the "unity" of certain common language, cultural tradition,
religion etc. The Nation is a soul, a spiritual principle.
- writes Ernest Renan in 1882 - Two things, which in truth
are but one, constitute this soul and spiritual principle. One
lies in the past, one in the present. One is a possession of a
rich legacy of memories, the other is a present day consent, the
desire to live together, the will to perpetuate the value of the
heritage... To have common glory in the past and to have common
will in the present; to have performed great things together,
to wish to perform still more - these are the essential conditions
of being a people (Renan, Ernest. What is a Nation?
in: Nation and Narration, ed. Homi K. Bhabha, Routledge,
London and New York, 1990, p. 19. The experience of the cultures
of absences seems to contradict Renan's assertion that the two
things are in truth but one. The common past - especially if it
is a past of shameful absences, traumas and defeats, doesn't lead
necessarily to a common wish to live together in the present.
There is no necessary connection between the principle of political
will and the principle of cultural tradition.
2.The unity of a state territory and the political emancipation
are late features of the nation; their origin could scarcely be
derived from any economic determinations. Sociologists and historians
as Eric Hobsbawm assert that "the national state" and
the "national economy" were not transformed to basic
economic mechanisms until the 19th century. Earlier - during the
period of 16 - 18 century, the development of capitalism was based
on state territories, which, however, had one unified mercantile
strategy. Hobsbawm points to the fact that economists from this
period (Adam Smith, for example) interpreted the state principle
in the economy as a rather mistaken one because it contradicted
to Smith's image of the free market, based of the free initiative
of the individual, the free function of capital and commodities,
etc. Such economic model tends to have as border-lines the whole
world - not a single national state and the national market. (Hobsbawm,
Eric Nationen and Nationalismen, Campus Verlag, Frankfurt
u. New York, s. 38.).
3.In Bulgaria, for example, the rise of Modernity is not connected
with an important Western invasion toward the Ottoman markets.
Neither is the traditional Marxist explanation of the Bulgarian
Revival period sufficient - that the real driving was the internal
bourgeois economic processes in certain regions of the country.
The latter explanatory model could not explain why the new types
of production and the new capital in certain Bulgarian cities
(Koprivshtitza, Panagyurishte, Kalofer, etc. - cities with trade
connections to Vienna, Istanbul, Leipzig, Budapest etc.) didn't
expand freely beyond any kind of national borders but formed limited
national economy. The functioning of money and commodities
is in itself expansionary and universal; there is no immanent
economic cause, which could stop it. There are other non economic
factors which put limits on it. Together with the economic rise
of the already mentioned Bulgarian regions there was a consolidation
of different ethnic groups at work. They were using in a totally
new manner old symbols and emblems or created new ones for their
identification and confrontation against the Others (the Greeks,
the Turks, etc.) Through the expansion of these new narrations,
self-images and images of the Others, through the establishement
of the new educational institutions and the following codification
of the language a new symbolic economy was created.
4.In the so called "normal case" the territory is the
most powerful institution because the conquered and controlled
territory represents the principle of co-ordination and unification
of all other national institution. In Bulgaria during the revival
this was not the case - there was an Empire (already received
as foreign) in which vast Oriental space the imaginary territory
of the Bulgarians was always threatened to loose its determination
and to disintegrate into unclearness. That's why there was a permanent
need for a symbol for this non-existing territory - an imaginary
mechanism, which should hold the integral national "body"
together - the Bulgarian lyrics of the Revival are full of such
geographical and political "visions" articulating the
hypothetical borders and ecstatically baptizing them through the
names of the great Bulgarian rivers, mountains, planes, etc. The
typical titles of such lyrical "maps" were symptomatic
- Where is Bulgaria, Where was I born, etc.
5.Eliade, Mircea, The Sacred and the Profane, Harvest
Book, New York, 1959, p. 122 - 125.
6.I would like to make some acknowledgments. My paper
develops some ideas of Benedict Anderson, Ernest Gelner and Eric
Hobsbawm which I tried to translate in a kind of a neo-Lacanian
key; in respect to this translation I was influenced by the book
of the Slovenian psychoanalyst and philosopher Slavoj Zizek (Zizek,
Slavoj The Sublime Object of Ideology, Verso, London -
New York, 1989). It corresponds also to some motives in the
Bulgarian debate in the articles: Георги
Стойчев, В гонитба на вестта. Емигрантът като Платонов философ,
в. Култура, бр. 46, 15.11.1991; Валери Стефанов,
Метафизичната родина на Димо Кьорчев, Литературен форум
- Литературна христоматия, януари 1992 г.; разговорът на Владимир
Трендафилов, Калин Янакиев, Владимир Левчев Изток - Запад,
Литературен вестник, 31.1. - 7. 2. 1992; Мая Спасова, Българската
общност, в. Култура, 24.04.1992; Георги Каприев
Култура на отъствието, Литературен вестник, бр.
17- 23, 1993 etc.